Sunday, January 17, 2010

Evidence for God

An excerpt from The Reason for God by Timothy Keller

Evil and Suffering May be (If Anything) Evidence for God

"Horrendous, inexplicable suffering, though it cannot disprove God, is nonetheless a problem for the believer in the Bible. However, it is perhaps an even greater problem for nonbelievers. C. S. Lewis described how he had originally rejected the idea of God because of the cruelty of life. Then he came to realize that evil was even more problematic for his new atheism. In the end, he realized that suffering provided a better argument for God's existence than one against it:

My argument against God was that the universe seemed so cruel and unjust. But how had I got this idea of "just" and "unjust"?...What was I comparing this universe with when I called it unjust?...Of course I could have given up my idea of justice by saying it was nothing but a private idea of my own. But if I did that, then my argument against God collapsed too--for the argument depended on saying that the world was really unjust, not simply that it did not happen to please my private fancies...Consequently atheism turns out to be too simple.

Lewis recognized that modern objections to God are based on a sense of fair play and justice. People, we believe, ought not to suffer, be excluded, die of hunger or oppression. But the evolutionary mechanism of natural selection depends on death, destruction and violence of the strong against the weak--these things are all perfectly natural. On what basis, then, does the atheist judge the natural world to be horribly wrong, unfair, and unjust? The nonbeliever in God doesn't have a good basis for being outraged at injustice, which, as Lewis points out, was the reason for objecting to God in the first place. If you are sure that this natural world is unjust and filled with evil, you are assuming the reality of some extra-natural (or supernatural) standard by which to make your judgement. The philosopher Alvin Plantinga said it like this:

Could there really be any such thing as a horrifying wickedness [If there were no God and we just evolved]? I don't see how. There can be such a thing only if there is a way that rational creatures are supposed to live, obliged to live...A [secular] way of looking at the world has no place for genuine moral obligation of any sort...and thus no way to say there is such a thing as genuine and appalling wickedness. Accordingly, if you think there really is such a thing as horrifying wickedness (...and not just an illusion of some sort), then you have a powerful...argument [for the reality of God].

In short, the problem of tragedy, suffering, and injustice is a problem for everyone It is at least as big a problem for non belief in God as for belief. It is therefore a mistake, though an understandable one, to think that if you abandon belief in God it somehow makes the problem of evil easier to handle."

Dr. Keller's argument thus far may sound cold and irrelevant to the real life sufferer. Later in the chapter, he continues:

"...for every one story in which evil turns out for good there are one hundred in which there is no conceivable silver lining..."So what if suffering and evil doesn't logically disprove God?" such a person might say. "I'm still angry. All this philosophizing does not get the Christian God 'off the hook' for the world's evil and suffering!" In response the philosopher Peter Kreeft points out that the Christian God came to earth to deliberately put himself on the hook of human suffering. In Jesus Christ, God experienced the greatest depths of pain. Therefore, though Christianity does not provide the reason for each experience of pain, it provides deep resources for actually facing suffering with hope and courage rather than bitterness and despair."


Russell Holloway said...

Nice post Katdish. Thanks for reminding us of what C. S. Lewis said and expanding on that.

Funnyrunner said...

well written and interesting, thanks!

Maureen said...

One of the most extraordinary things happening in Haiti is people of faith and of every economic status - people who before would never have crossed the street to acknowledge each other - are coming together and singing into the early hours of morning. They continue to pray and to believe and they do so as one.

~*Michelle*~ said...

"...the Christian God came to earth to deliberately put himself on the hook of human suffering."

good stuff.

This was a great read, Katdish....thank you!

Robin Arnold said...

Exactly. And on so many levels.

nAncY said...

thanks, kat.
these are timely words.

L.T. Elliot said...

Much food for thought. I'd never viewed suffering in this manner before, nor thought of how is proves/disproves the existence of God. It speaks to both my logical and spiritual halves and now both are mulling it over.

♥ Kathy said...

Great post!

Graceful said...

I just finished Keller's book recently, and just yesterday went back to reread what he had to say about God and suffering. I would highly recommend this book, especially for those more inclined to an analytical mind. I'm sort of "black and white" and a lot of his arguments really resonated with me.

sherri said...

" provides deep resources for actually facing suffering with hope and courage rather than bitterness and despair." I can personally vouch for that!

This was filled with great reminders during a time when our heads are spinning! Thank you.